This was originally posted on Betable's Game Monetization blog.
Hey all, check out the video below. I would love to embed it but the HTML embed doesn't seem to be working at this time (or I am failing to get it to work). Still, it's a great video and worth a watch. I have also provided cliff notes below for those that want them.
Roger Dickey is the creator of Mafia Wars, one of the most successful social games of all time, and was the GM of FishVille at Zynga before becoming an international product advisor in their Japan and China divisions. He recently spoke at our Game Monetization meetup event, "Money Talks". There's a ton of great wisdom in this video and I wanted to share it with the Gamasutra community.
Engagement is the heart of your game
Roger Dickey started off his presentation outlining the three R’s of social games:
Reach, Retention, and Revenue.
Roger argues that if these were in a graph, engagement would be in the center. He compares engagement to the heart of your game because “it is effectively pumping blood to every other part of your game”. Engaged users will help you reach more people by sharing the game with your friend, they will retain longer, and they will be more willing to pay.
One of Roger’s most interesting points was that “fun pain” was the key to social games’ success. Think about how a player needed to click each square to plant or harvest their crops in Farmville. This is a perfect example of “fun pain”, something that is simultaneously entertaining and a little bit annoying. This also gave Zynga the opportunity to upsell the player on pain-reducing items, such as a tractor that clicked four fields at once. These items were extremely popular among players, even though they only existed because it was painful to play the game in the first place!
Grind vs. Spam vs. Pay
Social games work in much the same way when it comes to special items. This is frequently employed with special items that are built via a combination of parts. Typically, you can earn the parts for the special item in three ways:
Players almost always start with Grind or Spam to kick off their pursuit of the item. However, as the player grows weary of grinding and doesn’t see the response he was hoping for from his friends, he is left with a partially completed item and no use for the parts. Now, the user is willing to pay for the item to be completed.
Estimating your game’s monetization
A simple, rough formula to estimate how much a casual social game could be broken out as follows:
This is a pretty high level estimation that begs the question...
What do people pay for?
Roger found that people pay for the following in social games:
Players will pay for anything that is socially surfaced in the game because you’re presenting your farm, city, or avatar to your friends.
This drives demand for exclusive items: people will pay more when there is only a limited number of an item available, or to get things before other players.
Items that make the game more convenient and tip the “fun pain” scale more towards fun are worth a lot to a wide variety of players.
Having certain features or aspects of gameplay only become available for a fee can be an effective monetization model, as we see often with freemium software.
Hardcore players, especially males, will pay to get a competitive advantage against their opponents.
Your players want their friends to play and by helping them, they increase their friend’s chance of sticking with the game. Once power becomes social, it becomes much more valuable and people pay for it.
Roger found that random chance was a huge incentive for people to buy. We wrote a blog post that highlights the power of the Mystery Box that covers this in more detail.
Players will pay for progress or temporary power in a game, especially a competitive one.
Surprisingly, people pay very well to advance the story. They feel a sense of progress when completing quests and will pay to overcome roadblocks in that progression.
Roger was adamant about launching with metrics already in place. Furthermore, he pushed for game studios to record every single click or action that players did in the game. This requires reams of data but is well worth it. Much of the insights that Roger gained about player behavior was from data that he didn’t even know he needed when he build his metrics systems.
Breaking your users into cohorts is an incredibly important tactic for monetizing your game. Roger’s recommended cohorts goes far beyond the typical hardcore vs. casual groupings. He recommended using the following cohorts:
Mine the theme space
When working at Zynga as GM for Fishville, Roger Dickey and his team spent a good amount of time doing what he calls “mining the theme space”. They read books on fish and put up fish posters around the office to make sure that they were immersed in the world they were creating. That way, when it came time for game design meetings, the team was usually full of new ideas for gameplay and content.
Master plan for monetization
Lastly, Roger emphasized the need for a master plan for game monetization. This means including monetization from the very onset of the design’s inception. To this end, he offered up a number of tips and strategies from his game monetization toolkit:
Your obligation to your creations is a real driver of engagement. You don’t want your fish to die and float to the top of your tank, looking ugly and showing your neglect for all your friends to see.
It is worth noting that players care much less about payer vs. non-payer fairness than a game designer would think.
When working to launch a competing game in Japan, Roger studied Kaido Royale extensively. In this Mafia Wars-style game, you needed to not only buy a gun to use but also the bullets to fire the gun, and this consumable use system helped the game monetize extremely well.
“If you give somebody a huge bucket of candy, they’re gonna love the candy for a week, and then never want any again. If you give them 10 pieces a day, they’ll keep coming back for years”.
“Farmville was at one point mostly a canvas for people to decorate on.”
In any game where the long term goal is to build, territory expansion is a big part of the game.
A necessary evil that helps the game retain users by keeping it interesting and dynamic.
Content grab bags
When buying multiple items at once, players simultaneously feel like they’re getting a deal and that they’re buying something more substantial than a virtual gun.
This is a decent way to increase revenues, just don’t let sponsored content “go all Myspace and take over the whole game.”
This doesn’t monetize well, but low level players will purchase free currency to advance faster or complete quests.
This means mechanics like ‘do this 10 times and master it’ in Mafia Wars. “It’s kind of funny sitting there as a game designer and being like ‘our game is already kind of mundane... what if we make everyone do things 10 times?’ Well, it can work.”
First time buyer incentive
To get people to convert from free-to-paid, first time buyer incentive gives players that haven’t purchased a ‘deal’ that gets them over that crucial first purchase hurdle.
The ability to wager on the outcome of your game could be a game changer. Betable is the first platform that makes it possible for game developers to implement this in their games.
Roger Dickey’s presentation gave us a ton of insight into game monetization and the psychology behind social game mechanics. A big thanks goes out to Roger for sharing his strategies with our San Francisco Game Monetization meetup.